10 Best Substitutes for Vanilla Bean Paste

Substitutes For Vanilla Bean Paste

We use various ingredients throughout the cooking process to make our food tastier and get the most flavor.

When baking or preparing a fabulous dessert, we add extra components to produce a delicious dish. Vanilla bean paste is something that is frequently incorporated, particularly in baking.

A lot of people love the mild and sweet flavor of vanilla. Vanilla beans, frequently used in cuisine, make vanilla bean paste. The taste of vanilla has always been distinctive.

It is one of the necessities for baking. Vanilla enhances the flavor of food while also adding depth. Ice cream, chocolates, baked products, coffee, and even nuts contain it.

A thick paste with a strong vanilla taste is called vanilla bean paste. It includes vanilla beans scraped off the pod and vanilla extract.

Because real vanilla beans are pricey and, in a manner, too much labor, vanilla bean paste is frequently utilized in recipes that call for whole vanilla beans.

Vanilla extract, vanilla bean paste, and whole vanilla beans can all be combined. There are many uses for vanilla bean paste. It may be used in custards, creams, and moist sweets. The paste has a robust vanilla taste.

Additionally, it leaves behind little black vanilla seed particles that enhance the aesthetic attractiveness of your meal.

You can use substitutes for vanilla bean paste if your recipe calls for it and you don’t have any on hand. The alternatives will yield comparable outcomes for you.

Vanilla bean paste can replace vanilla extract, entire vanilla beans, vanilla powder, and vanilla essence. They all give food a delicious vanilla taste. We shall go into further depth on these substitutes for vanilla bean paste:

What are Vanilla Beans?

Vanilla bean paste is made from vanilla beans or pods, as the name suggests. The vanilla pods are ground into powder, combined with a little amount of vanilla essence to create a syrupy beverage with specks of vanilla bean.

So you may use the beans in their place anytime you can’t get your hands on the vanilla paste.

To acquire the maximum flavor and essence when using vanilla beans as a substitute for vanilla bean paste, make sure the beans are fresh and plump.

You may scrape them and utilize them as-is or use these tiny beads to make vanilla bean paste when cooking sweets that need heating.

Vanilla beans are the ideal ingredient since they provide a light tint to your mixture and have the same flavor as vanilla bean paste.

Use one complete pod and scrape the seeds for each tablespoon of vanilla bean paste called for in the recipe you’re using. But vanilla may spoil, especially if mold begins to form on it.

You can identify molds by looking at fuzzy or spongy materials around the pod. Usually, the pod must be thrown away when you see these molds.

Substitutes for Vanilla Bean Paste

Here are the substitutes for vanilla bean paste.

1. Almond Extract

One of the most frequently forgotten substitutes for vanilla bean paste is almond extract. Almond extract, manufactured from a nut, has a strong scent that makes it a fantastic ingredient for baking and cooking. 

Additionally, because of its consistency, you may use it in place of or in addition to vanilla extract. To make the extract, bitter almonds are combined with water and oil.

Amygdalin, a poisonous substance in bitter almonds, is broken down and eliminated during extraction. As a result, benzaldehyde is created, giving the extract its powerful, vanilla-like nutty aroma.

You may anticipate a mild yet appealing influence on baked items when using almond extract as a substitute for vanilla bean paste, as well as a semi-sweet taste with a trace of bitterness.

Additionally, you may use the same amount of almond extract as the vanilla bean paste.

2. Imitation Vanilla Extract

A cheap and accessible substitutes for vanilla bean paste is imitation vanilla extract. It is a popular component that can be found in most people’s pantries, making it a good fallback if no other options are available.

Imitation vanilla extract is not made with real vanilla beans, unlike pure vanilla extract. Vanillin is an artificial component that gives it its taste.

While some assert that genuine and fake vanilla extract taste identical, that is absurd. While it does a good job mimicking natural vanilla’s flavor and scent, the finished product lacks the same depth and authenticity. And just because there aren’t any alternatives does not make it a wrong choice.

Therefore, if fake vanilla extract (also known as vanilla essence) is all you have and you need to replace vanilla bean paste, go ahead and use it!

3. Vanilla Essence

In essence, vanilla essence is vanilla extract’s knockoff. Most people mistakenly believe that vanilla extract and vanilla essence are interchangeable.

A produced liquid with an artificial vanilla flavor is called vanilla essence. There isn’t any actual vanillin in it. Other additives, including sweets, colors, and preservatives, are also included.

Even though it imparts a vanilla taste to food, it is not as potent as vanilla bean paste. Vanilla essences can be used as substitutes for bean paste since it still imparts a light vanilla taste to baked items.

Utilizing vanilla essence has the benefit of being liquid. You may thus add it to your baked products, especially those that demand moisture or are creamy.

Use one teaspoon of vanilla bean paste in place of each teaspoon of vanilla bean paste that your recipe asks for.

4. Maple Syrup

Although maple syrup has a different consistency than vanilla bean paste, it may be among the excellent substitutes for vanilla bean paste, particularly if you have maple syrup in your cupboard and have run out of all the other possibilities.

Depending on the hue, several grades of maple syrup are available. You may use darker-colored maple syrups for baking and as a 3rd substitute for vanilla bean paste.

In place of vanilla, maple syrup may be a wonderful addition to your recipe since it has a distinct aroma that is unmatched by other flavors. It also has a rich flavor and a hint of sweetness.

I would say that maple syrup has a flavor similar to vanilla, which is fantastic. It’s ideal for cookies and other pastries since it hints at caramel and prunes flavor.

5. Vanilla Powder

You might want to try vanilla bean powder if you’re making vanilla icing for a cake and out of vanilla bean paste. Because it doesn’t include any liquid or alcohol like vanilla extract, it offers a rich, powerful taste and generates a firmer consistency.

Since the vanilla powder is derived from vanilla beans, you can substitute it for vanilla bean paste when it is in its purest form.

Other producers turn powdered vanilla beans into vanilla sugar, a sweeter version, by mixing confectioner’s sugar with the powdered vanilla beans. You may still use them, but don’t anticipate your baked items to taste entirely vanilla.

6. Honey

The least anticipated option on our list of substitutes for vanilla bean paste is honey. But since both vanilla and honey are among nature’s best tastes, you may substitute one for the other.

Honey has a thick texture like vanilla bean paste, a sweet flavor, and a light scent. Most baked items with the “healthy” label substitute honey for table sugar.

Numerous vitamins, such as the B vitamins riboflavin, niacin, pantothenic acid, and important minerals like copper, calcium, iron, phosphorus, magnesium, manganese, and zinc, are present in raw honey.

All of these factors add to the health advantages of eating raw honey, making it not just a preferred flavor but also a nutritious sweetener.

7. Cinnamon

Despite having diverse uses in the kitchen, cinnamon and vanilla beans complement one another. Their perfume is overpowering and aromatic and may be used to flavor any cuisine. Cinnamon is a spice whose taste may be described as spicy and bitter.

One of the most well-known spices in the world, cinnamon is always used in inventive ways. It may be used in teas, hot chocolate, baking, and cooking, and some people even add it to soups to give them a spicier, more exotic flavor.

8. Vanilla Bean Seeds

The vanilla bean contains these seeds, obtained by removing a portion of the bean and using a knife to scrape the bean’s skin. These tiny, fragrant vanilla seed flecks, often referred to as vanilla bean caviar, add a ton of flavor to any meal.

9. Lemon Juice

Lemon juice can assist you in obtaining at least some scent and flavor if you’re truly pressed for time and don’t have anything else to add to flavor your baked products or dishes. You may enjoy the lovely, lemony fragrance by adding the juice of half a lemon to any cake or pastry preparations.

10. Vanilla Sugar

These substitutes for vanilla bean paste function similarly to conventional granulated sugar. They include dark vanilla bean extracts due to the industrial infusion of vanilla flavor into white sugar.

Italy, Austria, and Hungary are a few countries that utilize vanilla sugar often. In recipes for sweet desserts, one to two tablespoons of vanilla sugar will replace one vanilla bean.

However, because the recipe calls for vanilla sugar, you should reduce the ordinary sugar. They are ideal for use in recipes where vanilla beans are normally used.


Without a doubt, one of the most loved flavoring ingredients in the entire globe is vanilla. The relaxing perfume and the delicious flavor are so irresistible that they may be found in every dessert cuisine.

One of the most specific items to substitute is vanilla bean paste. Few things will give your food the authentic vanilla flavor, but those work very well as alternatives.

Most substitutes for vanilla bean paste are more affordable, accessible, and practical. The best thing is that these variations mostly come from vanilla so that the distinctive flavor won’t be lost.

Finding one that meets your taste won’t be difficult because many possibilities are available. Give it a try. The range of textures and taste intensities leaves the ultimate decision up to your liking.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like